| 2003 - Rob Umbelina - Punting - 36.0 yds/punt |
| 2003 - Glen Kelly - Converts - 14/14 100% |
| 2002 - Mike Jones - Receiving - 843 yards |
| 2002 - Mhoudy Halbouni - Punt returns - 467 yards |
| 2002 - Mhoudy Halbouni - Interceptions - 5 |
| 2001 - Mhoudy Halbouni - Interceptions - 5 |
| 2001 - Paul Testa - Defensive Point Average - 27.2 DPA |
| 1998 - Ben Carswell - Punting - 38.9 yards/punt |
| 1998 - Mike Davis - Defensive Point Average - 33.3 DPA |
| 1997 - Troy Cooper - Kick off returns - 279 yards |
| 1996 - Ben Carswell - Punting - 36.4 yards/punt |
| 1992 - Dino Cifaldi - Fumble recoveries - 4 |
| 1991 - Jeff Beraznik - Receiving - 52 receptions/906 yards |
| 1990 - Tony Daugherty - Scoring - 96 points |
| 1990 - Dave Woodey - Kick offs - 49.1 yds/kickoff |
| 1990 - Glen Smith - Interceptions - 9 |
| 1989 - Moe Lawrence - Kick off returns - 276 yards |
| 1988 - Myke Weis - Punt returns - 365 yards |
| 1988 - Steve Alexander - Fumble recoveries - 4 |
| 1987 - Courtney Shand - Receiving - 31 receptions (Stat based on # of receptions at this time) |
| 1987 - Myke Weis - Kick off returns - 349 yards |
| 1986 - Brad Halls - Kick off returns - 478 yards |
| 1985 - Jim Reddon - Receiving - 42 receptions (Stat based on # of receptions at this time) |
| 1983 - John Frizzell - Interceptions - 8 |
| 1982 - Ron Almeida - Scoring - 104 points |
| 1982 - Tom Boyd - Passing - 2364 yards (No QB efficiency rating at this time) |
| 1982 - Ron Almeida - Receiving - 48 receptions (Stat based on # of receptions at this time) |
| 1981 - Ron Almeida - Scoring - 109 points |
| 1981 - Ron Almeida - Receiving - 45 (Stat based on # of receptions at this time) |
| 1981 - Tom Borton - Punting - 38.8 yds/punt |
| 1980 - Joe Graves - Punting - 38.6 yds/punt |
| 1979 - Joe Graves - Passing - 1160 yards |
| 1978 - Tom Cudney - Receiving - 36 receptions (Stat based on # receptions at this time) |
| 1976 - John Disbrowe - Interceptions (West Division) - 6 |
| 1976 - Mike Butts - Punting (West Division) - 37.2 yds/punt |
| 1975 - Paul Walls - Receiving |
| 1975 - Daryl Stephenson - Punting |
